We’ve Got to Stop Decorating With Everything New – A Room Without History Feels Inert

The room is finished. Everything is in place. The palette works, the furniture fits, the objects are arranged on the shelves. And something is still wrong. It feels correct and somehow inert. Like a hotel room that someone put a lot of thought into.

The problem, almost always, is that everything in it is new.

Not new as in recently installed. New as in purchased from the same moment in time, from the same aesthetic register, with the same lack of history. Nothing in the room has been anywhere before. Nothing has been used by anyone. Nothing carries evidence of a life that preceded the one currently being lived in it.

It was designed to feel inhabited. It doesn't. And that's exactly what people eliminate when they furnish a home all at once.

In my own work, the piece I fight hardest to keep is usually the old one. A worn leather chair that the client wants to replace. A ceramic that came from somewhere else. A piece of furniture that is clearly from a different decade than everything we're putting around it. I almost never let them go, because I know that thing will be the reason the room works.

The old thing is usually the thing you remember when you leave the room. It's the thing that makes everything around it feel more real rather than less.

I've thought about why this works, and I think it comes down to evidence. A room full of new things has no evidence of time passing. The objects in it haven't been touched enough to show it. They haven't been moved around or reconsidered or kept because someone loved them specifically. They were selected and installed, and they sit there being correct.

One old thing changes this entirely. It has been somewhere before it was here. Someone else made a decision about it. It has a surface that shows use. It asks a question about how it got into the room, and that question makes the room feel like it has a story.

The fix is not complicated. It is not a whole room of vintage pieces or a commitment to any particular aesthetic. It is one thing. One wooden object that has been oiled and used. One ceramic that is clearly handmade and old. One piece of furniture that was not designed in the last five years. One light fixture from a different era than the rest of the room.

That one thing will do more for the room than almost any other single decision. Not because old things are inherently better than new things. Because a room that contains only one moment in time reads as incomplete, even when it's finished.

The rooms I love most feel like they've been gathered rather than purchased. That's not an accident. It's a decision that someone made early, usually by keeping one thing that didn't match and letting the rest of the room answer to it.

Interior designer Nina Takesh is one of Homes & Gardens' Editors-At-Large for By Design, sharing her thoughts on decor. See the rest of her articles here.

Love beautiful design ideas, expert advice, and inspiring decor trends? Sign up for our newsletter and get the latest features delivered straight to your inbox.