My So Connecticut Life: The Thanksgiving Prep Routine I Swear By After 10 Years of Hosting

Here's how I start preparing for Thanksgiving the weekend before – tackling the shopping, cooking, and table setting early so I can actually enjoy the holiday stress-free

My so Connecticut Life Thanksgiving Prep
(Image credit: Kaitlin Madden)

I have spent more than a decade writing about homes and interiors, but My So-Connecticut Life is personal. I live in a 1937 Colonial in the small town of Easton, Connecticut, with my husband, three children, and our dog. Seven years in this house have taught me which farm stands and vintage markets are worth the detour, how to set a table without stress, and the small routines that make a home feel like home. Every other Saturday, I’ll share a glimpse into life in Connecticut – where I’m shopping, how I’m hosting, and the seasonal rituals that shape the year.

If you’ve ever hosted Thanksgiving, you know that without a few days of advance preparation, the dinner planned for 3 p.m. can easily end up being served closer to 6 p.m. – likely with a burnt, undercooked, or completely forgotten side dish among the casualties.

Beyond smoothing the logistics of cooking an unusually large meal for an unusually large group, getting a head start allows me to actually enjoy the holiday. I can spend time with my family instead of rushing around the kitchen, overheated and stressed, while everyone else wonders when we’re going to eat.

After hosting many of my family’s Thanksgivings over the last 10 years, I’ve landed on a preparation routine that begins the weekend before. The key, for me, is to focus on the meal prep, cleaning, and table-setting jobs that ensure I can focus on the real cooking on Thursday (and that I have all the right ingredients to do it).

Get Everything on Paper

planning for thanksgiving

A look at my most important pre-Thanksgiving ritual: writing the to-do list.

(Image credit: Kaitlin Madden)

I start my Thanksgiving planning the way I start any project: with a few old-fashioned, handwritten lists. On Saturday morning, I sit down with a notebook and start by writing out the full menu, including who is making or bringing each dish.

From there, I divide my to-dos into four categories: cooking, cleaning, table setting, and inventory. That last category covers everything from checking that I have enough flour to confirming that there are enough plates, glasses, and serving dishes for everyone. I write down every task I can think of, then highlight anything that can be completed in advance. Finally, I turn the master list into smaller daily plans and grocery lists.

For the cooking schedule, I work backward from the time we plan to eat. Next to each dish, I note its cooking time and temperature, whether it can be made ahead, and if it can be served at room temperature or needs to be hot. This is usually when I make my annual discovery that the menu really requires three ovens and I only own one.

As a workaround, I look for dishes that can cook at the same temperature, be prepared in the slow cooker (I have a large, inexpensive one I use only when I host big holidays) or go into the oven while the turkey rests, and I jot down notes about that, too. After getting all of these things out of my head and into my notebook, I start the actual planning.

Take Inventory Before I Shop

thanksgiving preparations

I always check in on my spice drawer before I do my Thanksgiving shopping to make sure we have enough of the staples.

(Image credit: Kaitlin Madden)

Once the menu and to-do lists are settled, I take inventory before I go shopping. I start with the obvious ingredients, such as flour, sugar, butter, herbs and spices, but the list goes beyond food.

I also make sure we’re stocked with the cooking and cleaning essentials I tend to assume are on hand until I discover otherwise (this is usually at the exact moment I need them). These include things like foil, parchment paper, trash bags, paper towels, my favorite hand soap, dishwasher detergent, and enough containers for leftovers.

The key is to look at each item rather than rely on memory. A canister containing half a cup of flour might not be empty, but it also isn’t going to make a pie. I buy anything on the restocking list, along with shelf-stable ingredients, over the weekend, then make a shorter trip closer to Thanksgiving when I pick up the turkey and shop for the more delicate produce, fresh herbs, and anything else that won’t keep as well or that I missed the first time.

Prep the Tableware and Serving Pieces

thanksgiving preparations

I rinse lesser-used items that tend to sit in cabinets for a few months at a time to remove and dust that may have settled on them.

(Image credit: Kaitlin Madden)

The food may take center stage at Thanksgiving, but the meal wouldn't be possible without, to double down on this analogy, the supporting cast: utensils, dishware, linens and china. Since there's no cooking time or risk of spoilage with these items, I prep them on the weekend.

I open the dining room cabinets and pull out the things we use only a few times a year, like crystal glasses, silver serving pieces, and candlesticks. They're usually pretty clean, but most of them still need a quick rinse or polish before they're ready for the table. This is when I count the glasses and serving pieces, as well as whatever plates we'll be using, to be sure we have enough to go around.

I also wash and iron table linens, then stack them on the table so they're ready to go on Wednesday.

planning for thanksgiving

Air dry clay place cards take 2-3 days to fully dry, so I make them over the weekend.

(Image credit: Kaitlin Madden)

Each Thanksgiving, I like to make a different type of place card if I have the time, so I do that over the weekend as well. This year, I used air-dry clay, thin velvet ribbon, and a glaze to make name plates for each person, and they can be used as Christmas ornaments later.

thanksgiving serving dishes on a table

My serving dishes have their assignments.

(Image credit: Kaitlin Madden)

And finally, I match each serving piece to a dish. This is something I started doing after realizing one Thanksgiving that I'd run out of decent-looking serving bowls. Now, after I rinse or polish any serving pieces, I place a small card inside each one with the name of the dish it will be used for and add a serving utensil.

Aside from preventing another shortage of serving bowls, this also makes it easier for other people to help get dinner on the table. If someone offers to transfer the vegetables or set out the cranberry sauce, they don’t have to ask me which bowl to use or where to find a serving spoon.

Get Ahead on the Cooking

cranberries in a dutch oven

Cranberry sauce is one of the dishes I always make ahead.

(Image credit: Kaitlin Madden)

On Sunday, I start cooking. I focus on things that hold up well enough that you can't tell they were made ahead, or things that actually taste better after a few days. Depending on my Thanksgiving menu, that might include cranberry sauce, pie dough, salad dressing, stock, chopped vegetables, or a casserole that can be refrigerated or frozen.

I label each container with its contents and any remaining instructions, such as "thaw in the refrigerator" or "bake at 350°F for 30 minutes." It saves confusion and means I don’t have to find the recipe again while several other things are cooking.

Shop My Prepping and Hosting Essentials


By Sunday night, the menu is finalized, the serving pieces are organized and a few dishes are already prepared. There's still a good chance I'll have to run back to the grocery store before Thursday, but I've gotten enough done to make sure dinner is served close to schedule and that I'll have time to enjoy the day.

Love beautiful design ideas, expert advice, and inspiring decor trends? Sign up for our newsletter and get the latest features delivered straight to your inbox.

CATEGORIES
Kaitlin Madden
Executive Editor, Homes & Gardens

Kaitlin Madden Armon is a writer and editor covering all things interior design and offers an insight into her own home in her new column, My So-Connecticut Life. Her work has appeared in Real Homes, Architectural Digest, Martha Stewart Living, Refinery29, Modern Luxury Interiors, Wayfair, The Design Network, and lots more. She graduated from Northeastern University with a degree in journalism and currently lives in Connecticut with her husband, three kids, and black lab.