I've Fallen in Love with the All-Clad D3 Stainless Steel Pans after Weeks of Testing – It's Non-Toxic, Heirloom Quality I Can Trust

After years of relying on non-stick pans, I finally decided to try a classic All-Clad stainless-steel pan set. I haven’t looked back.

I tested the pieces included in the All-Clad S3 Everyday 5-piece set for about a month to see if I could live without non-stick pans for good. I was happily surprised by what I found.

The testing came at just the right time, as my old trusty non-stick pans had started to chip. After using this non-toxic cookware set for a few months, I will admit that I have fallen in love with it and will certainly be expanding my collection.

Product Specifications: All-Clad D3 Stainless Everyday 3-Ply Bonded Essential Cookware

Design and First Impressions

Image 1 of 4

All-Clad’s D3 Everyday 5-Piece Set looks timeless on my kitchen counter and on my stovetop. Although some brands try to get your attention with flashy colors or modern design elements, All-Clad’s D3 Everyday Set is a classic, shiny stainless-steel set that goes with any type of decor and will never go out of style.

The set shipped in minimalist packaging, using only enough plastic to protect the included pots and pans.

The D3 Everyday Set has some weight to it due to its solid construction, but it’s easy to move around.

All-Clad’s D3 Everyday Set requires a little more work than non-stick pans. However, prepping them for use doesn’t take long, and cleaning isn’t as difficult as I feared.

What I appreciate most is the sense of longevity the set offers. Made by All-Clad, it feels like cookware designed to last for years. Unlike many non-stick pans that need replacing every few years, this is cookware I expect to keep in rotation for a long time, without constantly checking for the scratches or wear that signal it’s time to replace your pans.

I also don’t have to worry about inadvertently exposing my children to toxic materials or 'forever chemicals', sometimes found in non-stick cookware, so the extra work is worth the trade-off for me.

I had previously turned to a ceramic-coated stainless-steel pan, hoping for greater longevity. However, I quickly became disillusioned when my pricey pan warped after just a few months. These stainless steel pans feel like heirloom quality.

Cooking Performance

Image 1 of 5

After washing the pans with soap and water, I put the set to work right away. Cooking with stainless steel initially felt unfamiliar; I was used to non-stick, but the adjustment was easier than expected.

With a little heat and oil, stainless steel can behave much like a non-stick surface. According to All-Clad’s instructions for the All-Clad D3 Everyday Cookware Set, the key is proper preheating. Start by warming the pan, then add a few drops of water. When the droplets begin to dance across the surface (the Leidenfrost effect), and a faint wisp of vapor appears, the pan is ready to cook in.

At first, the process sounded more complicated than it is. In practice, it takes just a couple of minutes, and after a week of cooking with the set, it quickly becomes second nature. Many stainless steel cookware brands recommend a similar method.

Then, I tested the pans using four standard ingredients:

• Onions: I make fried onions at least once a week, so using a pan that produces perfectly caramelized onions is important to me. In every test, my D3 Everyday pan sizzled evenly, creating perfectly caramelized onions. The onions never stuck, and they colored nicely without scorching.
• Sauce: To test how well the set handles sauce, I simmered an entire jar of Rao’s marinara sauce in the pan. It started simmering in one minute and 22 seconds. The sauce simmered evenly throughout the pan.
• Seared tofu: Because I am a vegetarian, I seared tofu as part of my testing. The D3 Everyday pan produced a perfect golden brown, although it did stick slightly in places. This was easily removed with my spoon, however.
• Fried eggs: My fried eggs fried easily with nice, crispy edges. They slid out of the pan easily on almost all of my trials. There was one exception where I believe I did not add enough oil to the pan to make it non-stick, so I attribute that mistake to user error rather than a fault with the pan. For this trial, my egg still slid out easily, but I noticed some burnt residue left behind.

Overall, my D3 Everyday pots and pans are a joy to use. They need more care and attention than non-stick pans, but no more than any other stainless-steel cookware. Learning how to use and clean them properly was a bit of a learning curve. However, getting the hang of it didn’t take long, and the extra steps became second nature and easy to execute within a week.

Cleaning, Storage and Maintenance

All-Clad’s D3 Everyday line is relatively easy to clean, though not as easy as non-stick cookware. After most uses, I was able to clean the pots and pans in the set with warm water, soap, and a sponge. Occasionally, I needed to soak the pans in warm water with a few drops of soap for about 10-15 minutes to loosen some stuck food. That’s something I rarely had to do when using non-stick pans, but it’s not difficult. I can go about my day as the pans soak without giving them a second thought.

All-Clad recommends using baking soda to remove burned-on food and a cleaner such as Bar Keepers Friend, from Walmart, or Bon Ami, from Amazon, to remove other types of tough-to-clean spots. In my weeks of testing, I never had to use anything other than soap and water to make my cookware sparkle like new. Since All-Clad has clean lines, there aren’t any nooks and crannies for food to get stuck in, making cleaning easier.

All-Clad recommends hand-washing its cookware rather than placing it in the dishwasher. While some users report running their pots and pans through a dishwasher without issue, the brand advises against it, noting that repeated dishwasher cycles can gradually damage stainless steel and lead to small surface pits.

According to All-Clad, these pits won’t affect cooking performance, but they can detract from the clean, polished finish the brand is known for. To preserve the look, I plan to hand-wash my All-Clad D3 Everyday Cookware Set and keep it in good condition for years to come.

Storage has been straightforward, too. I can easily fit every piece from the set into my standard-sized kitchen cabinets.

What Customers Say About All-Clad's Stainless Steel Pans

Fellow customers also love All-Clad’s D-3 set.

On the All-Clad site, verified shopper Kelley shared, 'Little bit of a learning curve after using non-stick cookware for years, but I'm getting the hang of it and learning a few new tricks. Early results are great, and I love the heft and style of these pots and pans. They clean up nicely and look like new when dried right after washing.'

Fellow shopper A. Mason adds, 'I absolutely love this set. It's comfortable to hold, well weighted, and doesn't slip on my glass range. I accidentally forgot my pot on the stove and boiled the water out of it – and it had black spots on the bottom and a rose-gold hue (extreme oxidation) overall, and I was able to clean it up within minutes with a quick soak in Barkeeper's friend (note: Not too long or it will dull the finish). It was amazing, cleaned right up, and didn't warp. It's as good as new. I love this set and plan to use it for a lifetime!'

Overall, customers looking for an alternative to non-stick pans that they hope will last a decade or more are happy with All-Clad’s D3 Everyday Set.

Most of the negative reviews I saw center on unhappiness with All-Clad’s customer service. Some reviewers complain about food sticking to their pans, but it’s unclear whether those reviewers followed All-Clad’s recommended steps to prevent sticking. Moreover, because the D3 Everyday collection is not non-stick, some sticking is expected from time to time.

My Verdict: Should You Buy The All-Clad D3 Stainless Everyday Essential Cookware Set?

The All-Clad D3 Everyday Cookware Set is an excellent stainless-steel option, particularly for home cooks who are reconsidering traditional non-stick pans. After all, even Ina Garten relies on All-Clad cookware in her Hamptons kitchen.

Compared with non-stick cookware, stainless steel requires a few extra steps, both when preheating the pan and when cleaning up afterward, so it may not be the most convenient choice for every home cook. The pieces are also not dishwasher safe, which is worth considering before investing.

Still, for anyone seeking heirloom-quality cookware, the set is an excellent choice. The pots and pans feel exceptionally durable, cook evenly, and maintain the polished, professional look stainless steel is known for.

From a value perspective, the set also makes sense. All-Clad’s D3 pieces are built to last far longer than most non-stick cookware, which often needs replacing every few years. While I originally chose the D3 Everyday Set to round out my existing collection, the five-piece configuration also works well as a starter set, covering the essentials needed for everyday cooking as well as more ambitious recipes.

In fact, the D3 Everyday pans have quickly become my go-to cookware. After a little trial and error, I’ve found that the extra attention stainless steel requires is a small trade-off for the durability, performance, and peace of mind the set provides.

How We Test Cookware at Homes & Gardens

The best cookware has to tick all the boxes: Versatility, manageable weight, safe materials, brilliant cooking performance, and, crucially, ease of cleaning.

You can read more details about how we test cookware at Homes & Gardens, including how long we vet each piece for and specifically which recipes we trial.

I test all cookware in my own home under real-world conditions – usually mid-week meals cooked after work, putting the pans through regular use over a range of recipes to get a good understanding of how these pans perform and fit into the everyday, hard-working home.

What Else to Shop

To get the most out of your stainless steel cookware, I’ve rounded up six essential tools that make it easier to cook cleanly, without introducing unnecessary toxins back into your kitchen.

All prices were correct at the time of publishing.

Once you have made your investment, be sure to explore how to clean all types of cookware, including stainless steel, to ensure your set stays looking new for as long as possible. Reading more about the common cleaning mistakes people make with stainless steel can also help prolong the life of the D3 Everyday Set.

Love the latest product news and helpful shopping advice? Sign up for our newsletter and get the latest features delivered straight to your inbox.