I Tried Made In's Seasoned Cast Iron – It's Beautiful, Non-Toxic, and Surprisingly Low-Stick, but Seriously Heavy

After using the Made In Seasoned Cast-Iron Skillet and Dutch oven over the last few months, it is clear that it is quality, heirloom-quality cookware that delivers on reliability and delicious results time and time again.

As with all the best cast-iron cookware, the Made In pieces come with the familiar cast-iron learning curve and high maintenance regimen. But they make up for it in their performance, with relatively low-stick surfaces and great heat conductivity, providing crisp and golden results over a range of dishes.

This is how I found cooking with the Made In Seasoned Cast Iron, the minor complaints that docked half a star, and why I think it is ultimately a fantastic choice for those looking to get into cast iron cooking.

Product Specifications: Made In Seasoned Cast-Iron Cookware

Design and First Impressions

Image 1 of 6

As with other Made In products I have received in the past, the Seasoned Cast-Iron cookware came packaged with no plastic, nestled in sturdy cardboard packaging that was easy to break down and recycle.

Both the skillet and the Dutch oven arrive pre-seasoned with a flaxseed oil blend, meaning after a wipe-out to remove any factory dust, they are ready for use. As always, it is recommended to start cooking with higher-fat foods so the oils can contribute to the initial seasoning, avoiding acidic dishes that could damage the metal.

I was enamored by the overall aesthetic of these pieces, especially the Dutch oven. I am used to bright enameled cast iron for these pieces, so the rustic, cast-iron exterior with stamped lid was a nice change. It has the look and feel of a vintage piece but with modern durability and peace of mind. One thing I will note, however, is that it is incredibly heavy. The eight-inch skillet is easy to move around; however, the Dutch oven (especially with the lid) is by far the heaviest piece of cookware I have tested.

For reference, the oven with lid weighs in at around 15 pounds. This is five pounds heavier than the Le Creuset Modern Heritage Dutch oven I reviewed, and two pounds heavier than the Made In Enameled Cast-Iron Dutch oven I reviewed earlier this year. I was recovering from a back injury during testing, and I could certainly feel this added weight every time I stooped to take it in and out of the oven. This is not to mention the way the oven racks bowed under the pressure. It is certainly something to keep in mind before buying.

Cooking Performance

The Made In Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet

Image 1 of 13

When testing a cast-iron skillet, I use the same tests to help establish how well they perform in comparison to one another.

Overall, the Made In Seasoned Cast-Iron Skillet performed well. It was not as low-stick as some of the other skillets I have tried, but it was far from the worst. Foods cooked and browned evenly, the pan heated throughout, and when food did stick it was usually down to needing more oil. I was generally pleased with the results, cooking with minimal frustrations.

• Burgers: The first thing I cooked in the pan was a burger, using the oils and fats to help break in the seasoning. The patty browned evenly, developing a decent crust; however, it was not quite as crisp as the Victoria Cast-Iron Skillet I was using alongside it, and the fats did burn a little to the base even when cooking on a low heat. I also found that the buttered bun stuck and tore on the surface afterwards, too. Overall, however, the results were commendable, and it made a nice burger quickly with minimal fuss.
• Sausage Hash: This is a go-to quick protein lunch for me, frying up pork sausages with onion (often tomatoes in a non-cast-iron pan), and starchy potatoes. This was another test the skillet passed with ease, with everything browning and crisping nicely. There was some sticky residue on the pan after cooking, however, which proved slightly annoying to remove, but it was far from an excruciating experience.
• Pancakes: I had mixed results with the pancakes, but I believe this may have come down to user error. The first pancake, cooked with plenty of oil, released perfectly, browning nicely across the surface. The second pancake, however, stuck rather badly and I had to scrape it out. I had tilted the pan between pancakes to redistribute the oil as I usually do, but it seems this was not enough. The more oil, the better, it seems.
• Skillet Cookie: A skillet cookie is the perfect test of how a pan performs in the oven. I preheated the skillet before greasing and adding the dough, then baked. The cookie slid out of the pan surprisingly easily after cooking a little, leaving only a few crumbs behind. It had a crisp base and molten center, which is everything I am looking for.
• Fried Eggs: A fried egg is a true litmus test for a cast iron pan. This was one of the last things I tested, after the pan had been used and oiled several times. At this point, the egg cooked quickly and evenly, released with a good amount of oil and my silicone spatula, and developed a crisp skirt. Again, it is not the crispiest I have seen, but good nonetheless.

The Made In Seasoned Cast Iron Dutch Oven

Image 1 of 4

Being so used to cooking in an enameled cast-iron Dutch oven, I was not sure what to expect from a plain cast-iron option. Having only tested one like it before (the IKEA Dutch oven I compared to Le Creuset), I dove in with my usual tests, with the exception of my bolognese, avoiding acidic ingredients to protect the metal:

• Bread: There is nothing better than a quick, home-baked loaf. When baking, I am looking for a quick bake with a good rise and a crispy exterior, and the Made In Dutch oven delivered. After preheating and laying the dough inside, I cooked with the lid on before removing it for the last half to crisp the top. The resulting bread was fluffy on the inside and golden on the exterior.
• Chicken Casserole: I was worried that the skin on my chicken thighs would stick to the rough interior of this Dutch oven, but I am thrilled to say I had no issues with sticking at all during my tests. The chicken crisped and released easily, the vegetables softened without complaint, and the stock bubbled evenly from edge to edge. My only complaint during the cooking process was how heavy the full pot was with the lid. I was worried that my oven rack would snap when I loaded it in, and was relieved halfway through when I removed the lid to crisp the dumpling tops. Overall, the chicken fell easily off the bone, the dumplings were light and fluffy, and the vegetables were tender and buttery. It was everything I would expect.

Cleaning, Storage and Maintenance

Cleaning cast iron has never been a task I enjoy, luckily, with the right tools, maintaining the Made In Seasoned Cast Iron was not too difficult. With both pans, residue was most easily removed with a chain mail scrubber, available at Amazon. This is especially true for the Dutch oven, which has a rough surface that would damage or catch fibers from a sponge or cloth.

You have to dry cast iron immediately, which was easy enough for the smooth-milled skillet but proved tricky with the Dutch oven. The weight and size aside, the rough surface tugged the fibers of my dish towel, leaving particles behind. I couldn't find a way around this, either, which was frustrating.

Beyond cleaning, you need to season these as you would any other cast-iron cookware. I chose to use grapeseed oil from Walmart for this, spreading it thinly over the surface before heating on my stove for a few minutes. Generally, I had no issue with this, but once again I found that paper towel chunks caught on the rough Dutch oven interior.

Storing the skillet was easy, as it slotted into my usual pan organizer; however, I would advise storing the Dutch oven on a low, sturdy shelf, as the weight could damage higher shelving or pose a risk when lifted in and out.

My Verdict: Should You Buy The Made In Cast-Iron Cookware?

The Made In Seasoned Cast Iron is, all in all, a good option if you want quality, heritage-quality cookware. It did not blow me away in the same way the super affordable Victoria skillet did, nor is it as easy to use as the Made In enameled options, but it delivers good results with minimal fuss.

I can't fault them too harshly, but there are other pans I would personally choose based on price and/or weight that offer the same performance. They look beautiful, however, making them a worthy choice if the overall aesthetic of your kitchen, and making kitchenware into decor, is a concern for you.

The general consensus among shoppers agrees with me. With an average of 4.9 stars over 54 reviews on the Made In site, customers love that it is pre-seasoned, the beautiful design, and the non-stick qualities that improve with time (especially on the smooth skillet).

How We Test Cookware at Homes & Gardens

The best cookware has to tick all the boxes: Versatility, manageable weight, safe materials, brilliant cooking performance, and, crucially, ease of cleaning.

You can read more details about how we test cookware at Homes & Gardens, including how long we vet each piece for and specifically which recipes we trial.

I test all cookware in my own home under real-world conditions – usually mid-week meals cooked after work, putting the pans through regular use over a range of recipes to get a good understanding of how these pans perform and fit into the everyday, hard-working home.

What Else to Shop

When it comes to cast iron, you need to pay particular attention to cleaning and caring for cookware. To help maintain your new cookware, I have curated a selection of care essentials that I would not live without to prevent rust and ensure these heirloom pieces are still in perfect condition when you hand them down.

All prices were correct at the time of publication.

Not sure if cast iron is for you? We have a complete guide to choosing the best cookware for your home and cooking habits.

Love the latest product news and helpful shopping advice? Sign up for our newsletter and get the latest features delivered straight to your inbox.