I Didn't Expect a $25 Cast Iron Skillet to Impress Me This Much – The Victoria Pan Is Now an Everyday Favorite

When I first received the Victoria Cast Iron Skillet, I wasn't sure what to expect. After weeks of hands-on testing, however, I can safely say that it is one of the best pans I have ever cooked with. It has allayed all of my fears of cooking with cast iron.

I used the 10" Victoria Cast Iron Skillet for a series of tests from robust burgers to delicate eggs, and was blown away at how perfectly it performed time after time. I was planning on gifting it to my dad after testing, but now it is staying firmly in my own kitchen.

This is exactly why I think this is some of the best non-toxic cookware money can buy, and how it far surpasses its modest $25 price tag.

Product Specifications: Victoria 10-Inch Cast Iron Skillet

Design and First Impressions

Image 1 of 5

The Victoria Cast Iron Skillet is made in Colombia and looks similar to many of the other best cast iron pans, with a sturdy handle and helper handle to balance the weight. It's easy enough to hold with one hand if you have a strong grip, but the helper handle certainly helps if holding for a prolonged period.

The pan has two deep pouring spots on either side as well, which I found to be especially useful when I was pouring out some excess hot fat from the pan after frying burgers. They are shaped to prevent drips, which makes the process safer and simpler.

Arriving pre-seasoned with 100% non-GMO, kosher-certified flaxseed oil, the skillet is free from PTFE, PFOA, and other synthetic coatings, making it naturally non-toxic. The deep, smooth surface helps to prevent food from sticking. It is shaped specifically to allow for simmering sauces as well as frying, adding to its versatility.

Cooking Performance

When it comes to testing cast iron pans, I use the same tests to establish a baseline for performance, cooking meat, eggs, and pancakes to see how it handles searing and delicate release foods.

I could not find any fault with the Victoria Cast Iron Skillet in this regard. From first use, it delivered perfectly cooked foods that never stuck or burned, with the performance only improving over time as the seasoning developed.

The only thing to note is that the metal is so good at conducting and maintaining heat that the handle does become hot when cooking. I used a dish towel to lift it safely; however, you can also find custom-made Victoria silicone handle covers at Amazon.

Burgers

Image 1 of 6

When first cooking with cast iron, it is always recommended that you cook higher-fat foods to help develop the initial seasoning. I chose burgers for this, using a butcher's pork burger for my first cook.

I preheated the pan on a low heat and added plenty of oil (more than I usually would for the first fry), and my extra-large burger.

It took approximately six minutes a side to cook through completely, and flipped easily with no sticking at all. I was incredibly impressed, as I had prepared myself for a mess. The whole process was seamless, with the meat browning without burning, and cooking through while remaining juicy.

When it was done, I took it out and added the buttered bun to toast as the meat rested. Again, I expected it to stick, especially as there was a small amount of debris left from the meat. However, it toasted evenly without sticking or tearing. All in all, it was thoroughly delicious.

I repeated this test a few weeks later when I cooked two beef burgers. It was a squash to get both XL patties into the 10" pan, but I managed, especially as they shrank while cooking.

Having used the pan a few times between the two burger tests, I could see the effect of seasoning building up nicely. The beef burgers left absolutely no residue, with no sticking. It was simply perfect. The buns toasted nicely again, too.

Sausage Hash

Image 1 of 2

A quick sausage hash is a go-to lunch for me, and usually comprises of the vegetables I need to use up from the fridge. I used turkey sausages, onion, spinach, potato, and usually add tomatoes, although I omitted this from this test as it is inadvisable to cook high-acidity food in new cast iron.

As with the burgers, the meat browned evenly without sticking. The added finely diced onions caramelized quickly without scorching, and when I added starchy par-boiled potatoes, they hardly stuck. The pan did have some sticky residue on it after cooking, as to be expected, but it didn't burn, and was simple enough to scrape away with a wooden spoon.

Fried Eggs

Image 1 of 2

Fried eggs are the real litmus test for a good pan. They are incredibly delicate, and the fine whites can stick and burn if you are not careful.

It is safe to say I was nervous for this test, but the preheated and oiled pan delivered once again. Having cracked two medium eggs into the hot oil, they fried wonderfully, developing a perfectly crispy skirt that didn't burn.

When it came to releasing them from the surface with my spatula, they lifted instantly without putting up a fight. After flipping and cooking, the pan had no debris left besides small parts of white that I broke off accidentally when separating the eggs. It felt miraculous.

Pancakes

Image 1 of 2

It is safe to say that by the time I reached the pancake test, I was feeling incredibly confident. That said, I wasn't expecting just how perfectly it would master this task.

It is a truth universally acknowledged that the first pancake of any batch is the sacrificial pancake. It never turns out quite right. This pan proved that wrong. I used my usual protein pancake mix, preheated the pan on low, and oiled well. I poured in the first batch of batter, allowed it to bubble across the surface, and flipped.

As with the eggs, the spatula slipped beneath with ease. To my joy, the pancake was perfectly golden, as you can see in the video below. I had my friend on a video call with me as I did this, and even she was impressed at how perfectly the first pancake turned out.

I needed to redistribute the oil between each pancake, lifting the pan and tilting it to ensure the surface was evenly coated without having to add any more. The rest of the pancakes were just as perfect.

After cooking, the pan looked as if it had hardly been used at all. It was brilliant, and I will never cook pancakes in anything else again.

Cleaning, Storage and Maintenance

Cleaning cast iron has a bad reputation for being difficult, and while it is not as simple as throwing it in the dishwasher or soaking it in the sink for a few hours, with the right steps, I found it to be surprisingly straightforward.

Because the pan didn't struggle with sticking, I waited for it to cool to the point of being very comfortable to handle, and used a chain mail scrubber, available at Walmart, to dislodge any debris, and then a soft sponge to clean away any excess grease.

Hand drying after is a must to avoid rust, but besides this, I also found putting it back on the stove for two minutes on a very low heat to be particularly effective at drying the metal out.

Beyond that, I seasoned lightly after every use with a small amount of grapeseed oil, also at Walmart, spreading it around the pan with a paper towel. Once dried, I put it back into my Umbra Peggy Organizer (from Amazon) in my cabinet.

It is recommended that you deeply season your cast-iron pans on occasion, adding more oil and baking it off in the oven. I have not reached this point with my pan yet, but given the ease of use in every other task, I do not expect any trouble with this.

How Does the Victoria 10-Inch Cast Iron Skillet Compare?

There are two main pans in our review catalogue to best compare the Victoria Cast Iron Skillet to, both tested by our former Kitchen Appliance Editor and Chef, Lydia Hayman.

The first is the Lodge Skillet, which has previously held the place of our best budget option. That said, I think the Victoria Skillet has taken its place. With its smooth surface and pretty design, it outdoes the rough machined surface of the Lodge for a similar price. They both perform well, but the smooth triple-seasoned surface of the Victoria makes it simpler to use out of the box.

Our current 'best in class' is the Field Company Skillet. This exceptional pan was met beat per beat by the Victoria pan. The Field Co pan feels slightly lighter in comparison, and is just as low stick, making either an excellent choice for your kitchen. At $165, however, it is almost seven times more expensive than the Victoria pan, so it will come down to budget and personal preference on design.

The Victoria 10" Cast Iron Skillet is also adored by customers, with several glowing five-star reviews on the Victoria Cookware site. Each complements how easy it is to use, even for first-time cast-iron cooks.

Of the lower star reviews, one user commented on the pan arriving with rust; however, I can only see one of these, and I am sure that the company facilitated an exchange, given the pans' limited lifetime warranty.

My Verdict: Should You Buy the Victoria 10-Inch Cast Iron Skillet?

Without a shadow of a doubt, I think the Victoria Cast Iron Skillet is worth the money and then some. At only $25 for a 10" pan (at the time of writing), it is one of the most affordable pans on the market, and performs like pans four or five times the price.

It is perfectly suited to anyone who enjoys cooking with cast iron or who wants to start and is wary of some higher-priced pieces. It truly excels at frying meat and handles delicate frying with grace. I cannot wait to see what else I can create in it.

How We Test Cookware at Homes & Gardens

The best cookware has to tick all the boxes: Versatility, manageable weight, safe materials, brilliant cooking performance, and, crucially, ease of cleaning.

You can read more details about how we test cookware at Homes & Gardens, including how long we vet each piece for and specifically which recipes we trial.

I test all cookware in my own home under real-world conditions – usually mid-week meals cooked after work, putting the pans through regular use over a range of recipes to get a good understanding of how these pans perform and fit into the everyday, hard-working home.

What Else to Shop

If you care for cookware correctly, cast-iron can last for generations. To help you protect your investment, I’ve rounded up six of my favourite cleaning, seasoning, and maintenance tools to keep your new heirloom performing at its best for decades to come.

All prices were correct at the time of publishing.

Not sure if cast iron is for you? We have a whole guide to choosing the best cookware that will help you find the right type for your household.

Love the latest product news and helpful shopping advice? Sign up for our newsletter and get the latest features delivered straight to your inbox.