Benjamin Moore's Heritage Color Collection Features Nearly 200 Shades – But These 6 Iconic Colors Have Stayed Best-Sellers for Decades

Benjamin Moore's historical color collection has been making its mark in homes since its debut half a century ago. Inspired by the colors that defined homes in the 18th and 19th centuries, all of the collection's archival shades are steeped in heritage, but these six standout hues feel both fresh and enduring, able to transition into every home, modern, traditional, or somewhere in between.

A collection of timeless paint colors, the historical collection features 191 shades in total, but six shades have become some of Benjamin Moore's bestsellers, loved for their timeless elegance and versatility.

'Whether used inside or outside of the home, these colors enhance architectural details and bring character without feeling dated,' says Hannah Yeo, Senior Manager, Color Marketing at Benjamin Moore. 'Especially for exteriors, homeowners often gravitate toward colors they can live with for many years rather than colors tied to a particular moment. These heritage-inspired hues create a warm, welcoming feeling that feels timeless, which is why they continue to be favorites generation after generation.'

What Is Benjamin Moore's Historical Collection?

'The Historical Color Collection was introduced in 1976 during the American Bicentennial and was inspired by the colors found in 18^th and 19th-century architecture and interiors,' explains Hannah. 'These colors were carefully curated to capture the richness, authenticity and character of historical design while remaining relevant for how people live today.'

'Fifty years later, their continued popularity speaks to that timeless foundation. The collection includes sophisticated neutrals that bridge warm and cool palettes, as well as nature-inspired greens and other hues that feel both familiar and relevant. Each color carries a sense of history and architectural authenticity that resonates with homeowners and designers alike.'

'While the inspiration behind the palette is steeped in tradition, the collection's muted, sophisticated character transcends architectural style,' adds Helen Shaw, Director of Marketing (International), Benjamin Moore. 'For decades, these celebrated colors have complemented everything from contemporary to transitional spaces. With just the right level of saturation, the shades offer presence without taking center stage. They strike a considered balance between character and versatility, which is what makes them so enduring. These are colors that feel fresh and relevant today, while still having the depth and staying power to remain beautiful for years to come.'

Which Are the Best Selling Shades From The Collection?

Benjamin Moore recently revealed the best-sellers from this long-loved collection, and while some names will sound very familiar, other's where slightly unexpected...

No surprise Revere Pewter made the list. While some cool gray paints can feel sterile and short of depth, Benjamin Moore's Revere Pewter is one of those rare neutrals that brings quiet warmth and elegance to any room. It continues to be relied on for its grounding nature that enhances every architectural style.

'For those drawn to neutrals, Revere Pewter is a versatile bridge between warm and cool tones. This hue adds just enough warmth to make a room feel both contemporary and harmonious, whereas another best-selling neutral from the collection, Edgecomb Gray, is a slightly lighter and softer go-to neutral that can refresh a space, while also providing a warm, welcoming feeling due to the pink undertones.'

'Gray and warm neutrals provide balance,' says Hannah. 'They act as foundational colors that connect other elements in a space and create a sense of harmony. Their versatility is a major reason they’ve remained popular for so long.'

Greens are an expected addition to the mix too. 'Green continues to be a perennial favorite, with two standout options in the collection,' says Helen. 'Saybrook Sage is a harmonious blend of green and grey, while the dark, moody Essex Green brings a rich, hunter-green depth to a space. They highlight a strong desire to bring a soothing and grounding, nature-inspired energy into the home.'

'Both hues are hugely versatile and can therefore be used across many rooms in the home as a foundation to add accents in more saturated colours. For a living room, opt for all four walls in one of these adaptable shades with woodwork or trim in a darker gray for the perfect tonal scheme.'

It wouldn't be a heritage collection with a dark blue paint, and the iconic Hale Navy has been top of the best-sellers list since its arrival half a decade ago. It's your typical navy blue, with a deeply classic feel.

'Hale Navy remains the quintessential navy Benjamin Moore is known for, offering a softer, always-on-trend alternative to black or brown,' explains Helen. 'It works particularly well in busier spaces such as living rooms for making a versatile style statement. Alternatively, opt for this rich hue in the kitchen, on cabinetry in particular, for industrial styles or more traditional shaker kitchen designs.'

If you're planning on decorating with Benjamin Moore's Hale Navy, Helen suggests, 'Pair with a crisp white as the sharp contrast between the two hues will create a dramatic, yet calming effect.'

The best burgundy paints have made a comeback in recent years, and this feels like an unexpected addition among all the classic neutrals, greens and navies. Yet New London Burgundy, a rich red with brown undertones, has remained a consistent best seller from the Heritage Color Collection, evocative of neoclassical interiors of the 18th century.

'Burgundy offers warmth, depth and sophistication without being overpowering,' says Hannah. 'Unlike brighter reds, burgundy feels grounded and elegant, adding richness and character while maintaining a timeless quality.'

'New London Burgundy is another confident choice, blending red, violet and brown to create an elegant, welcoming statement,' Helen explains. 'This elegant hue works particularly well with everyday earthy tones such as beige or taupe to create a feeling of rustic warmth. Opt for a matte finish to provide an almost chalky appearance, which in turn will help to soften the bold color, making it supremely livable.'

From deep burgundies to rich forest greens, these six timeless shades have proven their timelessness. Heritage-steeped yet still current, they bring lasting sophistication to every space. 'Ultimately, these color families are versatile, emotionally resonant, and easy to incorporate into a variety of design styles, which is why they continue to endure,' says Hannah.

Love beautiful design ideas, expert advice, and inspiring decor trends? Sign up for our newsletter and get the latest features delivered straight to your inbox.