5 Vintage Decorating Mistakes That Make Homes Look Stuck in the Past

Living room with pale pink grasscloth walls, wooden coffee table, blue and cream sofas and armchairs and mahogany tables with large lamps — (Image credit: Brian Bieder)

Jump to category:

1. Forgetting About Balance
2. Being Too Literal
3. Matching Furniture
4. Neglecting Scale
5. Accenting Rather Than Anchoring

The pros of adding vintage pieces to your home far outweigh the cons. They add depth, character, and personality to spaces of any style. BUT, there are some vintage decor mistakes that are easy to make and could be making your home look dated rather than chicly unique.

Nothing beats the character that vintage brings. However, it's easy to get ahead of yourself when decorating with vintage and forget the all-important power of balance. We've all fallen in love with a style or era, be it a specific range of fine china or a furniture maker you're always on the lookout for, and while being sympathetic is important, it's contrast that makes these pieces truly sing.

1. Forgetting About Balance

Entryway with round marble table, vintage books, wooden console with marble bust and lamp and large tapestry on wall — A transitional living room is decorated with a variety of vintage pieces, from the tapestry wall hanging to the aged wooden console table.

While there's nothing wrong with showing off your collection of antiques, it's important to scatter newer pieces amongst the preloved gems to retain a balanced, cultivated feel. Consider how much of a room should be vintage to avoid an overwhelmed space that feels incongruous to your architecture.

Interior designer Liz Williams explains, 'Vintage and antique pieces add so much character to a room, but if not mixed in properly, a room can feel too matchy, dated, or dingy. This also happens when everything is from the same era and lacks a thoughtful mix.'

Mixing modern and traditional design will prevent your space from feeling fusty or outdated. Liz continues, 'My recommendation is to mix vintage and antique pieces from different eras with newer pieces. As an example, a contemporary painting over an antique French chest, or a vintage settee with a clear acrylic coffee table. Breathe new life into your vintage pieces while ensuring cohesion in design by focusing on contrast. Old pieces have pretty patinas that pair beautifully with new pieces with texture and pattern. The goal is a collected look!'

Sites like 1st Dibs and eBay are stocked with a range of vintage and antique styles to shop, whether you're looking to invest in foundational pieces or more decorative accents. To bring a modern feel to counteract historic pieces, look to stores like IKEA for a modern, pared-back feel, or Anthropologie for a luxurious, playful edge that pairs beautifully with characterful pieces.

Lauren Sullivan, Founder & Curator of Well x Design, says, 'Another misstep is prioritizing nostalgia over balance. Vintage and antique pieces have incredible character, but they need contrast. Without a mix of scale, materials, or something contemporary to ground them, a room can feel heavy or overly themed.'

2. Being Too Literal

Entryway with dark brown walls, vintage wooden console with rattan tray and vase of flowers on top and a vintage metal lamp — A vintage console table sits at the center of this dark, moody entryway, bringing a homely, lived-in feel that's matched by the antique table lamp and framed print.

It's only right to want to be sympathetic when adding decorating with antiques or vintage, but be careful to avoid the literal route, as this is what makes a home feel too much like a time capsule.

Lauren says, 'One of the most common mistakes I see isn’t using vintage pieces – it’s using them too literally. When every element in a room comes from the same era and stays within the same style lane, the space can start to feel like a time capsule rather than a home that has evolved.'

Introducing your vintage treasures alongside other styles will give them more presence and create a curated, collected feel. Lauren continues, 'Vintage decorating works best when it feels collected over time rather than recreated from a single moment in history. The goal isn’t to replicate the past – it’s to let it inform the present in a way that feels intentional and alive.'

Interior designer Lauren Saab agrees. 'Even authentic antiques lose their authority when nothing challenges them. When every element belongs to the same decade, the room starts to feel staged instead of lived in. Vintage pieces feel strongest when they exist alongside simpler materials like linen, plaster, or natural wood. That contrast keeps the space feeling current.'

3. Matching Furniture

Vintage kitchen with white shiplap walls, vintage wooden dining table and chairs, large rug, gingham curtains and low iron chandelier — A farmhouse kitchen comes to life through lived-in details, namely the wooden maker's chairs that contrast with the dark mahogany dining table.

If you want to avoid creating a space that feels pastiche rather than transitional, stop matching your furniture. While there's nothing wrong with a set of dining chairs, a room filled with identical furniture can feel like a cookie-cutter design rather than homely and unique.

Interior Designer Emily Jiles from Maggie Griffin Design explains, 'In my opinion, it’s time to ditch the matching furniture sets! Matching furniture sets make your home feel mass-produced, straight from a catalog, and instantly date a home. If your goal is warm and welcoming with touches of charm, they’ll fall short as they lack character and interest.'

Nailing your furniture scheme starts with embracing vintage furniture trends and scattering them throughout your home. Emily continues, 'Choose pieces that complement each other, but without matching. If your sofa has legs, choose a skirt for the base of your coordinating club chairs.'

She adds, 'Employ a mixture of upholstery styles, textures, and arm styles. An English arm on a piece of upholstery immediately warms the space. Don't be afraid to mix wood tones and styles of case goods, such as a pair of painted end tables next to a sofa with a darker wood coffee table. Mixing tones and finishes makes the space feel like it was collected over time, and it tells a story.'

4. Neglecting Scale

Hallway with shiplap walls, vintage console table, basket and modern art — A vintage console table frames this elegant hallway. Decorated with a rustic basket and a modern canvas, it's a simple yet sophisticated setup that proves the power of balancing the past and present.

Scale is always important in interior design, but when decorating with vintage, it's what makes or breaks a space. A mid-century daybed might work in an open-plan living room, but in a smaller home office, it could dominate. Equally, a wicker dining chair could sit beautifully in the corner of an entryway, but in a dining room, it could get swallowed up by a large table.

Lauren Sullivan explains, 'Proportion also plays a role. Some vintage furniture was designed for different room sizes and lifestyles, and if the scale isn’t thoughtfully considered within a modern floor plan, it can unintentionally make a space feel dated.'

'I love pairing pieces across periods – and playing with scale in unexpected ways to keep a room feeling layered and current.'

5. Accenting Rather Than Anchoring

Bedroom with shiplap walls, a blue nightstand with a glass lamp and a vase of roses, a rattan armchair and a mahogany antique bedframe — An antique mahogany bed frame acts as the focal point in this charming bedroom. The rattan armchair and rustic pottery bring an added layer of homeliness to the design.

Whether you're decorating with vintage art or adding a Persian rug to your space, treating preloved pieces as accents rather than focal points can detract from their beauty. Instead of using them to 'fill the gaps', give your vintage pieces presence by making them heroes in their own right.

Lauren Saab explains, 'Using vintage pieces as accents instead of anchors weakens the room. Vintage elements bring weight and credibility, but only when they define the space. A worn rug, aged wood table, or ceramic vessel immediately adds depth. When those pieces lead, and everything else stays restrained, the room feels layered rather than dated.'

That's not to say you need to make vintage the entire theme of your space, it just means bring attention to the preloved piece you do have. For example, you could decorate with vintage fabrics and upholster a bedframe in a ditsy floral, or you might make a piece of furniture like a midcentury coffee table the star of the show in your living room.

While it's important to be sympathetic when bringing vintage pieces into your home, it's the balance that makes past-loved treasures come to life. Layering your items will create contrast and give each piece rightful presence within your scheme.

Mixing your vintage pieces and scattering them throughout your home will ensure it doesn't feel stuck in the past or overly pastiche.

TOPICS