Worlds Best Homes

The house that inspired Gatsby's mansion is on sale for $13 million – and it's extraordinary

This beautiful home is said to have been the inspiration for F. Scott Fitzgerald – and we can see why

Long Island Gatsby house
(Image credit: Elliman)

Designed in the late 1920s by famed architecture firm McKim, Mead & White, the French Normandy-style mansion that is widely believed to have inspired the fictional 'East Egg' in F. Scott Fitzgerald's classic novel The Great Gatsby has gone on sale. 

Once owned by Mary Harriman Rumsey, a champion of social reform who founded the Junior League of the City of New York, and was the daughter of railroad tycoon E.H. Harriman and sister to New York Gov. W. Averell Harriman, this notable and historic estate, is located on Long Island’s coveted Gold Coast, and is listed at $12,900,000 by agent Maggie Keats through Elliman.

Its grounds are outstanding but the interiors are quite simply beautiful, too. Take the tour – it is a great chance to see one of the world's best homes

House in Long Island / Gatsby house

(Image credit: Elliman)

The art of living well is evident nowhere more than on the water and this home is as enchanting, seductive and sublime as its surroundings.

House in Long Island at Gatsby house

(Image credit: Elliman)

The 14-bedroom main house is situated on 5.3 waterfront acres, which includes patios with views of the Long Island Sound, lush gardens, a tennis court and a private 391ft sandy beach on The Long Island Sound. 

  • The world's most beautiful eco houses – from forest dwellings to city homes

Garden in Long Island at Gatsby house

(Image credit: Elliman)

Beach in Long Island at Gatsby house

(Image credit: Elliman)

Also on the property is a sea-side guest cottage (below), six-car garage with guest quarters and a boat house. 

Cottage in Long Island at Gatsby house

(Image credit: Elliman)

Meticulously restored and renovated for modern convenience while retaining its historic grandeur, the home features many original details including moldings, millwork, ornate plaster ceilings, and oak floors. 

Garden in Long Island at Gatsby house

(Image credit: Elliman)

Finding the right balance of luxury and practicality was key to the masterful renovation. The mandate for the house was a feeling of cool serenity, of modern elegance, and an almost ethereal lightness tethered to the qualities of the site. The rooms, while expansive, embrace a human scale. Indoor and outdoor spaces manage to be both private and social. Recalling the past while paving the way for new memories, this is not just a house, it's a gateway to the way things should be.

Kitchen in Long Island at Gatsby house

(Image credit: Elliman)

With 12 foot ceilings, the first floor includes a kitchen and breakfast room with a large architectural skylight and side patio leading out to the vegetable garden.

Conservatory in Long Island at Gatsby house

(Image credit: Elliman)

Dining room in Long Island at Gatsby house

(Image credit: Elliman)

There is also a formal dining room, living room with fireplace featuring its original sculptural mantle, a library with French doors, beautiful oak bookshelves and fireplace, a playroom, office, and one-and-a-half baths.

Living room in Long Island at Gatsby house

(Image credit: Elliman)

in Long Island at Gatsby house

(Image credit: Elliman)

The second floor also boasts 12 foot ceilings, and a luxurious master bedroom suite with a private porch, massive dressing room and sitting room.

Living room in Long Island at Gatsby house

(Image credit: Elliman)

Living room in Long Island at Gatsby house

(Image credit: Elliman)

Living room in Long Island at Gatsby house

(Image credit: Elliman)

There is also an elegant rotunda with skylight, floating staircase and two large bedrooms with a full bath. 

Bedroom in Long Island at Gatsby house

(Image credit: Elliman)

in Long Island at Gatsby house

(Image credit: Elliman)

Dressing room in in Long Island at Gatsby house

(Image credit: Elliman)

A guestroom suite with fireplace and full bath, a nanny bedroom with full bath, a family room with fireplace and full bath, and a laundry room with fireplace complete the second level. 

in Long Island at Gatsby house

(Image credit: Elliman)

Child's room in Gatsby House, Long Island

(Image credit: Elliman)

Child's playroom in Gatsby House, Long Island

(Image credit: Elliman)

Two staircases lead to the third floor, where there are seven bedrooms, two full bathrooms, an exercise room, an office and more.

Garden room in Long Island at Gatsby house

(Image credit: Elliman)

A formal foyer with floating staircase captures the eye, and a front patio leads onto the lawn. A limestone loggia offers areas for seating and dining, and an outdoor fireplace overlooking the Sound. 

Listing pictures of 235 Middle Neck Road, Sands Point, NY courtesy of Maggie Keats/Douglas Elliman.