This Couple Built Their Forever Home on the Land Where They Married – So Every Design Detail Evokes Memories, Meaning, and Nostalgia

Some homes take years to acquire a sense of history. This one was designed with it from the start. Built on land that has been in the owners' family for more than 40 years – and where the couple once got married – this Kansas City home had some rather meaningful foundations to build on. The brief was to create a forever home that felt as though it had grown here naturally, gathering stories along the way. 'Our goal was to customize as much as possible while still making the house feel familiar and nostalgic,' says Tara Davis of architectural and interiors studio Cicada Co. And that is exactly how it feels.

Taking cues from traditional Southern architecture, the 2,500-square-foot home has the welcoming front porch, classic shutters, and time-worn aesthetic of a house with a few generations behind it. But look inside, and the details start to tell a much more personal story. There's a kitchen mural inspired by a painting from the owners' grandparents' home, a garden room that keeps the family's green fingers rooted in daily life, and even a pink toilet that proves a classic home needn't take itself too seriously. The result is a new-build with an old soul – and a personality all its own.

The setting may be urban, but the ambition was decidedly old-fashioned. In Westside, just west of downtown Kansas City, narrow lots often lend themselves to new builds that make the most of every available inch. 'Our clients wanted the opposite: something southern and traditional, with shutters and a real front porch, that felt like it had always been there,' Tara explains. The solution was to work with the site's limitations rather than fight them, widening the front facade as far as possible, working with a linear floor plan, and keeping the rooflines simple. 'We imagined it as an old farmhouse that had been added onto over time,' she adds.

With the land having been in the family for more than four decades, Tara and her team were thinking about how the property would work not just today, but years down the line. A land study helped them plan for a future garage off the alley, with the garden room positioned to connect to it when the time comes.

Just as importantly, the design had to preserve one of the site's loveliest assets: the sunset. 'We made one rule early: nothing could block the western sunset,' Tara says. That simple rule shaped 'more of the house than almost anything else' – including the positioning of the primary bedroom, where the bed aligns with the windows and the evening light. Inspired by the way historic homes let light in, they kept the foundation traditional but 'stayed open to eclectic moments that bring out their personality,' she continues.

The traditional architecture provides charming bones, but the interiors are where this home really lets its personality show. 'Southern traditional with clean lines. Classic with a punch' is how Tara describes the aesthetic – a balance of natural materials, unfussy finishes, and more unexpected flourishes. The larger rooms are kept light and relatively neutral, with natural wood, simple cabinetry and enduring finishes providing a backdrop for the family's evolving tastes. 'Their taste can shift over time through furniture, textiles, and accessories,' Tara explains. 'We saved the color for the smaller, divided spaces, where it’s easier to change down the road.'

That restraint makes the moments of color and pattern all the more delightful. In the smaller, more private spaces, Cicada Co. turned up the personality with colored trim, wallpaper, and playful plumbing fixtures – from a cobalt blue sink in the bar nook to the pink toilet in the powder room. 'Keeping everything else quiet is what lets those rooms stand out,' she adds. These aren't details chosen to impress a future buyer; they're there because they mean something to the people who live here. The clients, Tara says, 'were never worried about resale. They wanted the house to be theirs,' which gave the studio freedom to make more personalized choices. In fact, she sees bespoke design as the very foundation of the project: 'It wasn’t a feature of this project. It was the only way to do it.'

If there's one place where that all comes together, it's the kitchen. The clients asked for a simple white scheme, but Tara felt it needed something more memorable than cabinetry and countertops alone – 'we knew it needed one moment that would give it a story,' she explains. Her solution was to commission a hand-painted tile mural from KV Tile, inspired by a painting that had hung in the owners' grandparents' house.

The original winter landscape was reimagined as a summer scene, with flowers and foliage bringing it to life – and the family's children and pets making cameo appearances, too. 'It became an art installation built into the house,' she says. The mural was designed piece by piece, with careful consideration given to the color of the tile and the way the tones would contrast. It's a wonderfully nostalgic touch, and one that makes the room feel as though it could belong to this family alone.

That instinct to design around real life, rather than an idealized version of it, runs through the rest of the house, too. The garden room is part potting station, part mudroom and part homework headquarters, complete with a generous sink and a window that opens onto the deck, so the children can play outside while someone keeps an eye on everything from within. In the primary suite, a clever half wall allows the closet and bathroom to disappear behind the bed, keeping the focus on the light and those western views.

Mudroom, utility space, potting station, homework hub – this hardworking room has rather a lot on its to-do list. Situated just past the wraparound banquette in the kitchen, a spot designed to seat the entire family for Sunday dinners, this room provides storage for shoes, coats, gardening tools, potted plants, and craft paraphernalia. Separated from the kitchen by a half wall that lets in the light and painted in a soft, dusty blue, with a deep farmhouse sink, warm timber counters, and plenty of woven baskets, it feels lifted straight out of an English cottage. The family has tended a garden on this land for years, so giving that tradition space indoors was important. 'From there you step out into a big, fully fenced backyard, enclosed on three sides by the original limestone walls,' Tara explains.

The powder room is proof that a little space can have a big personality. Striped wallpaper sets a playful tone, while a gathered floral sink skirt, antique wooden mirrors, and warm brass fittings lend the room a soft feel. The celebrated pink toilet is the real star of the show. 'The whole room is full of pattern play and fun,' says Tara, who sees the rosy fixture as 'a little feminine touch in a house full of boys.' It's a lovely expression of the homeowners' personality – and, frankly, if you're going to have fun with your interiors, the powder room seems as good a place as any to go for it.

The primary bedroom is a lesson in making clever planning feel entirely effortless. A tall, blue-striped upholstered headboard brings a tailored feel to the room, set against botanical wallpaper panels that introduce color and pattern without overwhelming the space. There's a lovely collected quality to the mix, too: crisp white bedding, floral cushions and an antique bedside cabinet that looks as though it has a story of its own.

But the smartest detail is tucked just out of sight. 'We anchored the bed on a half wall, with the closet and bath hidden behind it,' Tara explains. 'The wall becomes the focal point, and the bed lines up with the windows and the sunset.' It's a neat solution to the home's narrow, linear footprint. 'The house sits on a hill with clear western views, so we gave them a place to enjoy that.'

The primary bathroom continues the home's old-fashioned theme, although there's nothing dated about the result. A rich, furniture-style wood vanity, marble counters, and brass fixtures bring a touch of quiet luxury, while glossy forest-green tiles give the walk-in shower a moodier edge. Delicate glass tulip sconces and an elegant mirror add a little softness, but it's the commissioned stained-glass window, crafted by local artisans, that really captures the spirit of the project. It's exactly the sort of detail you might expect to find in a much-loved period home, rather than one built from scratch. As Tara explains, the aim was to incorporate 'details you'd find in a house that's been around a while', giving the new-build a sense of history without sacrificing modern comforts.

What makes this home so special is that it never feels as though it was designed to look old – it is designed to be lived in, loved, and added to over time. From the family story woven into the kitchen to the practicality of the mud-meets-garden room, each detail has a purpose beyond simply looking lovely. For Cicada Co., that was always the point: not to recreate the past, but to give this family a home that feels as though it has a history – and a lot of life still ahead of it.

Shop the Look

Love beautiful design ideas, expert advice, and inspiring decor trends? Sign up for our newsletter and get the latest features delivered straight to your inbox.