The Controversial Mixed Material Backsplash Trend That’s Polarizing Designers – And Why You Should Avoid It if You Have a Small Kitchen

Decision fatigue is something we all experience during the renovation process, especially when it comes to kitchens. But the latest trend has taken some of the pressure off, removing the need to choose between different backsplash materials.

That's right, mixed material designs are the latest kitchen backsplash trend making waves, creating a layered look in an unexpected place. And while it's a look many designers are championing, not everyone is on board.

Here's everything you need to know about mixed material backsplash designs, why it's dividing designers, and how to decide if it's the right approach for your kitchen. Spoiler alert – if your cooking space is small, you might want to give this one a miss.

The Appeal of a Mixed Material Backsplash

We've been seeing mixed material backsplashes emerging onto the scene recently, adding a layered, textural look to kitchen schemes. This approach is all about visual interest, giving designs a more dynamic look.

'A mixed-material backsplash introduces visual and tactile contrast that gives your space a really custom feel. By breaking up a single surface with different materials, you create a more dynamic, layered look that feels like a curated part of the home’s architecture rather than a standard finish,' says Jamie Chappell, VP of Brand and Product at Fireclay Tile.

'It's really so space-dependent. Sometimes a space calls for a bit more depth and interest. Sometimes, all tile will feel too busy or overpowering, so mixing in a slab quiets the noise just a bit, or a full slab backsplash will feel too cold and sterile, and the addition of some tile helps create some texture and warmth,' says interior designer Allison Lind.

Kitchen trends have been heading in this direction for a while now, with zellige tiles offering a new, organic finish, while paneled kitchen backsplashes created something entirely unexpected.

Mixed materials feel like a natural continuation of this ethos, giving a kitchen the effect that mixing patterns or textures would in a living room or bedroom, just in a more appropriate way for a functional space. And that's exactly why they are growing in popularity.

'I think the appeal of mixed materials in any setting is that it creates a different texture and therefore a different story – it’s so much more interesting to the senses than one surface,' agrees Holly Vaughan, founder of Vaughan Design & Development.

The Materials That Work Best

A successful design depends entirely on the materials and pairings you choose. It's about more than what looks nice, rather prioritizing how the two materials blend and wear over time.

'Different materials introduce texture, depth, and interest to the space. Pairing something classic, like honed marble, with a more textural material, such as hand-glazed tile, allows the natural variation to create visual interest without feeling busy,' says Joan Enger, Principal at J. Patryce & Co.

'I don't think you can go wrong with a natural stone and tile pairing. I especially love the way a more organic or handmade (read: imperfect) tile feels against a marble – the elegance of a perfect stone juxtaposed with an imperfect handmade tile is so lovely,' Allison explains.

And this duo is perhaps the most popular with designers. 'Natural stone slabs and handcrafted tiles are a classic pairing because they offer a perfect balance of scale. The large, seamless movement of a marble or quartzite slab creates a focal point, while the tile’s texture provides a grounded, artisanal contrast,' Jamie adds.

For something a bit more natural that feels at home in a country kitchen or ranch-style scheme, wood is worth considering. 'Solid wood (teak, oak, or walnut) with marble or subway tile would be a lovely combination,' suggests Joan.

'Don't count out wood, though, either – it can be so versatile for adding warmth to the typically colder materials of a kitchen,' agrees Allison. 'We've used wood paneling against tile to achieve a rustic-meets-modern vibe in a cabin, as well as a more cozy classic vibe in a craftsman kitchen.'

The Practical Considerations

The most important thing to consider is how the two materials pair, less from an aesthetic perspective and more from a functional one. 'The main thing that people need to consider is the thickness of the material, as if the two materials need to meet on the same surface, then they need to be level,' says Holly.

Jamie echoes her advice, adding: 'The transition between materials is an important consideration since different materials rarely have the same profile. Consider using some sort of trim, like a round liner, to create a deliberate, decorative border between the two materials.'

You also need to think about where the materials are located and the extra properties they need to have, for example, if they are behind the sink or the cooktop. 'Practical considerations are important when more than one material is introduced,' notes Grazzie Wilson, Head of Creative at Ca’ Pietra.

'Each surface behaves differently in terms of heat resistance, porosity, and maintenance, so positioning matters. Materials placed behind a hob must cope with heat and cooking splashes, while those near the sink must tolerate repeated contact with water.'

The Downfalls of a Mixed Material Backsplash

While the benefits of a mixed material backsplash can make this feature seem like a great addition to your kitchen, designers say it depends on your space. You need to consider the details already present in your scheme and whether a busy backsplash will overwhelm your design.

'You really need to consider the room as a whole, not just creating some elaborate feature backsplash idea – if a backsplash isn't created with intention around the entire space, it will distract from it rather than empower it,' warns Allison.

'Is the rest of the room quite quiet and simple? Then a mixed materials 'splash can enliven the space. But if your cabinetry is intricate or you have fluting or other textural details throughout the space, you may want to keep things quiet at the 'splash.'

But the biggest reason designers advise against mixed material designs always comes down to size. 'There are circumstances where a mixed material backsplash is not the best solution. In very compact kitchens, adding multiple surfaces can make the wall feel busy, particularly if the cabinetry, countertop, and flooring already have strong character,' says Grazzie.

'Installation quality also matters because poorly planned joins or incompatible materials can cause maintenance issues over time. In those situations, a single continuous material across the backsplash can be the more practical choice,' she explains.

The verdict? A mixed material backsplash is a stylish addition in the right kitchen (A.K.A, not a small scheme), and with the right approach to installation. Marble and tile are a favored duo, but less expected materials like wood paneling work beautifully in more rustic spaces. It's simply a case of understanding what you kitchen can handle.

Love beautiful kitchen design ideas, expert advice, and inspiring decor trends? Sign up for our newsletter and get the latest features delivered straight to your inbox.