Butter yellow might be endlessly chic – but designers warn not to pair it with these colors that can ruin this soft subtle shade

Dubbed the 'new neutral' for 2025, there's much to love about viral butter yellow. Adding a softness and warmth to interior schemes with a subtle nod to vintage, butter yellow is both sophisticated and playful.

That said, the wrong color combinations can quickly throw off this stylish shade, with certain bold and dark tones overshadowing its softness, and cool neutrals appearing at odds with the inherent warmth of decorating with yellow.

Below, we explore the colors to avoid pairing with butter yellow, as explained by interior designers. By steering clear of these competing hues and reaching instead for the colors that go best with butter yellow, you can create a perfectly balanced butter yellow scheme.

1. Cool-toned whites

Pairing butter yellow with neutrals such as white is a wonderful way to achieve a pared-back, calming space, but it's important to choose the right shade of white paint. Cool-toned whites can feel out of sync when paired with a warming butter yellow, whereas warm white paints are harmonious alongside warm yellow tones.

'Butter yellow brings a warm, playful energy to a space, but it’s important to be thoughtful when selecting complementary colors. One shade to be cautious with is a cool or blue-toned white – think bright, pure whites often used on trim or modern furnishings,' explains designer Lucas Goldbach, Design Director at Chicago-based En Masse Architecture & Design.

'When paired with butter yellow, these cooler whites can make the yellow appear dull or even dingy by contrast. Instead, opt for a warm white, such as Benjamin Moore’s Swiss Coffee, which enhances butter yellow’s softness and creates a more cohesive, inviting palette,' recommends Lucas.

2. Bold and saturated tones

While cool whites can feel imbalanced with butter yellow, you may also want to steer away from saturated and bold tones. Since butter yellow is a soft hue, pairing it with overly loud and intense colors can detract from its delicate appeal, suggests NYC-based interior designer Marina Hanisch.

'Butter yellow is such a soft, creamy pastel – it has this beautiful way of catching light and bringing a gentle warmth into a space without overwhelming it. I usually steer clear of pairing it with anything too bold or saturated, because that can overpower its softness,' she explains.

'If you’re leaning into its neutrality, I would avoid pairing butter yellow with overly loud or neon hues, which can overpower its subtle sophistication,' agrees interior designer Christina Garcia Lysaught of Layered Dimensions Interior Design.

Instead of vibrant tones, opt for earthy color tones like Farrow & Ball's iconic Faded Terracotta, or a grounding, muted shade of blue like Benjamin Moore's Iceberg, for a colorful yet harmonious look.

3. Pastels

Designers also warn about much lighter, softer color combinations when decorating with butter yellow. While pastel room ideas alongside butter yellow can work well with certain interior design styles, they can appear insipid for some. 'When using butter yellow, avoid pairing it with pastels, which can look childish,' advises interior designer MK Smith of Smith Interiors.

'I avoid pairing butter yellow with pinks and other pastels that can make it feel too sweet,' agrees designer Heather Hilliard of San Francisco-based Heather Hilliard Design, who designed this bedroom with a butter yellow headboard. Instead of pastels, a light shade of gray is used on the walls to complement the yellow, achieving a soft look but with more depth and timelessness than pastels.

4. Black

You should also think twice before pairing butter yellow with black, since it can create too much contrast. 'I would most definitely avoid pairing butter yellow with black,' says designer Alexis Warren of Alexis Warren Designs. 'There is too much contrast with the softness of a butter yellow. I would recommend sticking with a color palette that has a similar saturation for a cohesive feel.'

New York-based interior designer Kathy Kuo also advises against high-contrasting pairings with butter yellow, adding: 'I would advise using butter yellow almost as a neutral and not trying to create super bold, contrasting moments with it. Let it be subtle and pair it with other light and airy tones.'

If you do want to team butter yellow with darker tones, consider decorating with brown, which can achieve a sense of drama yet with more warmth and less intensity than black. Farrow & Ball's Cola is a lovely soft, rich, warm brown paint that would work wonderfully with butter yellow, especially if used in smaller accents.

While designers generally steer clear of these butter yellow color pairings, you should keep in mind that color is subjective, and you can get creative with your schemes to best suit your own home. If you're feeling inspired to decorate with this happy shade, our favorite butter yellow decor buys are bound to elevate your home this summer.