Is it worth buying a pillow protector? We weigh up the options

Bedding experts explain the benefits of a pillow protector and whether it's a purchase worth making

How to choose the right size area rug for your bedroom; Neutral bedroom with green curtains by Marie Flanigan Interiors
(Image credit: Marie Flanigan/Julie Soefer)

When updating your bedding, it's wise to purchase protectors to make it last as long as possible. For instance, the best mattress protectors on the market shield your mattress from spills, stains, and dust, keeping it in good condition for much longer than if you simply went without.

So what about pillow protectors – are they entirely necessary? We consulted mattress and bedding experts to answer all of your questions. 

Is it worth buying a pillow protector?

Pillow protectors are thin fabric encasements that protect pillows from moisture, bacteria, and allergens, and some have cooling benefits, therefore helping you sleep better and more comfortably. 

It's common to buy protectors and toppers for your best mattress, but why should you buy one for your pillows?

white cotton pillow protectors

(Image credit: The Fine Cotton Company)

'In my opinion, you shouldn’t need a pillow protector if you have high-quality pillows and regularly wash your pillowcases,' says Stephen Light, CEO and co-owner at Nolah Technologies. 'The best pillows already have protective, breathable, moisture-wicking, and hypoallergenic outer layers. 

'Many modern pillows, like Nolah’s Squishy Pillow, feature removable covers you can machine wash.' So if you have good enough pillows, it might be an unnecessary addition.

Stephen Light
Stephen Light

Stephen Light is the CEO of mattress and bedding company Nolah. He studied medicine before spending two decades in e-commerce and marketing.

bedroom with blue and white bedding

(Image credit: Future PLC)

However, as well as the cooling benefits we mentioned above, there are some key benefits to having a pillow protector that might sway you. Zoe Doyle is an expert on all aspects of silk bedding at Mulberry Park Silks. In her view, there are three main reasons for using them. 

First, they keep your pillow in good condition by keeping the down or alternative filling inside your pillow where it belongs. Second, they're great for allergy sufferers: 'They can be game-changer for allergy and asthma sufferers because they prevent allergens like dead skin cells, mold and bacteria from collecting and building up within your pillows,' she explains.

Thirdly, she says pillow protectors prevent hair oil, sweat, and other unwanted elements from staining your pillowcase, meaning you don't need to wash your pillows so frequently. Good if you ever go to bed with damp hair or with moisturizer on.

bedroom with black panelling, artwork, bed and pillows

(Image credit: Future PLC / Chris Tubbs)

Interior designer Peri Lauren has her own bedding range and agrees that pillow protectors are a great way to give your pillows a longer life and avoid having to spend money replacing pillows too often. 'You can easily replace your protectors, it’s a great small investment in your pillows!' she says.

Does a pillow protector replace a pillowcase?

'Definitely not! Always cover your pillow protector with a pillowcase,' says interior designer and bedding expert Peri Lauren. 'The pillowcase is much prettier than a protector and you can sleep on it! Pillow protectors are not for sleeping on. They only protect your pillow.' Mattress protectors, at Amazon don't replace your bed sheet, and the same applies to your pillow protectors.

Jaime Jimenez from luxury bedding brand SFERRA agrees. 'A pillow protector serves as an additional layer between your pillowcase and insert. We do recommend protectors as they will elongate the life of your pillows, but a pillow case or sham should be placed on top of the protector,' says Jaime.

Ultimately, it depends on how much you are spending on your pillows and how frequently you'll be using them. Guest bedrooms might do without them, but if you want to keep your pillows looking their best, protectors are a worthy investment.

Millie Hurst
Section Editor

Millie Hurst is a freelance lifestyle writer with over six years of experience in digital journalism. Having previously worked as Solved Section Editor at Homes & Gardens and Senior SEO Editor at News UK in London and New York, Millie has written for an array of homes brands including Livingetc and Real Homes and was formerly Senior Content Editor at Ideal Home. She has written and edited countless features on home organization, decluttering and interior design and always hopes to inspire readers with new ways to enjoy their homes. She lives in Sheffield, South Yorkshire, and loves to weave nature-inspired decor and nods to time spent in Italy into her own home.