Do you need a new coffee maker? Here's how to tell if it needs replacing

Don't settle for subpar coffee

Do you need to replace your coffee maker: kitchenaid drip coffee maker on a countertop
(Image credit: KitchenAid)

If you've used your coffee maker every day for the last ten years, you might not have noticed some slow and slight changes that have been happening. To those in the know, taste shifts, slow brewing, and more maintenance are telltale signs that you need to replace your coffee machine. 

Upgrading your old coffee maker to one of the best coffee makers on the market comes with its benefits. It might be an investment, but you'll get better quality coffee, much quicker, and with less maintenance. It'll even save you money on wasted beans and bitter coffee.

It's a good time to look for a different type of coffee maker as well as reevaluate how often you clean your coffee maker too. For now though, we've asked experts to explain the signs it's time to replace your coffee machine.

Signs it's time to replace your coffee maker 

'The average lifespan of a coffee maker is about five years, but high-end models may last ten or more,' says Christenda Costa, CEO of Gadget Review. 'But while modern coffee makers don’t need to be replaced as often, there will come a time when your morning coffee leaves something to be desired.' 

1. Technical issues

coffee machine

(Image credit: Alamy)

'The first and most obvious sign it's time to replace your coffee maker is that your current coffee machine simply has issues. Coffee maker, both drip and especially espresso, have a number of electrical and mechanical components that wear out over time,' explains James Hyslop, coffee author at The Coffee Folk. 'While some of these are easily replaced, the fact that they are giving way is a good sign that you should at least consider upgrading. 

'Small technical issues (water dripping out where it shouldn't be, machine making funny noises, screen not working properly) are often the precursor and symptom of larger issues that are expensive to fix.'

'Excessive leaks or cracks in the water reservoir also signal age and wear. When basic cleaning and descaling can't resolve issues, it's time to retire the coffee maker and purchase a new one for the best quality drinks,' advises Johny Morrisson, coffee expert at Coffee About.

If you are looking to replace your coffee machine, you can check out our guide for the best coffee makers.

2. Taste shifts

Modern kitchen with Scandi influences and open pantry cupboard

(Image credit: Janis Nicolay)

'If your coffee starts to have an unusual or unpleasant taste or odor, it could be due to lingering residues inside the machine,' says Steve Spring, president of Seattle Coffee Roasters. 'No matter how much you clean it, some residues are stubborn and can alter the flavor of your brew.'

James Hyslop explains, 'This can be due to a build-up of limescale (and so can be fixed via descaling) but it can also be a sign that the machine is, for want of a better word, weary. 

'Machines, especially if they are on the cheaper side, have a used-by date and shelf life after which the coffee they produce will degenerate in quality and flavor.'

'And if you regularly taste metallic flavors or plastic notes in your coffee, the internal tubing and plastic components are breaking down, making replacement necessary,' adds Johny Morrisson.

Investing in a new coffee maker can ensure you are able to enjoy rich and flavorful coffee.

3. Long brewing times

Nespresso pod coffee machine on a countertop

(Image credit: Nespresso)

'A clear red flag I've noticed is when brewing time becomes inexplicably longer, indicating possible internal malfunctions or mineral build-ups slowing down the process,' explains Kayla Stavridis, head of marketing at Barista HQ.

'This could also indicate limescale build up and reduced heating ability - a sign the machine is wearing out,' adds Johny Morrisson.

If cleaning your coffee maker doesn't resolve this issue, it may be time to upgrade.

4. Decreased brewing performance

Kitchen pantry

(Image credit: Davonport)

'One of the most telling signs is a decrease in brewing performance,' says Steve Spring. 'If you notice inconsistent coffee quality, with some cups tasting weak and others overly strong, it might be your machine's way of saying goodbye. Extended brewing times are another red flag; it's a clear indication that the internal components are struggling.'

If your coffee tastes burnt or feels lukewarm, it's a clear sign that the machine is not maintaining the right brewing temperature. The ideal brewing temperature is between 195°F and 205°F. Anything outside this range can compromise the taste, indicating your coffee machine is past its best.

5. Constant maintenance and upgrades

The Philips 3200 LatterGo control panel close up

(Image credit: Philips)

'If your current coffee maker requires frequent repairs or has become challenging to clean and maintain, it might be more cost-effective and aesthetically pleasing to invest in a new, low-maintenance model that complements your kitchen's design,' advises Fred McGill, interior designer and founder of Next Modern Home.

6. Scale build up and difficulty cleaning

A coffee cup being filled in a coffee mahcine

(Image credit: Getty Images)

Even though it’s possible to keep the appliance running for as long as possible with proper cleaning and descaling, after prolonged use, the heating elements will naturally wear out over time,' explains Daniel Velikov, PR specialist at Fantastic

'Scale build-up can affect the performance of your coffee machine and make it challenging to clean. If your current model is particularly difficult to descale or maintain, it may be time to replace it with a more user-friendly option,' advises Angela Rubin, cleaning expert at Hellamaid.

7. Lack of aesthetic appeal

Kitchen area with a light blue aga, white marbled worktops and fitted cabinets, dark wood flooring

(Image credit: Jody Stewart)

'One of the most apparent signs that your coffee maker needs an upgrade is if it looks outdated and no longer aligns with your kitchen's design aesthetic,' says interior designer, Fred McGill. 'Modern coffee makers come in sleek, stylish designs that can seamlessly blend with contemporary interiors, adding a touch of sophistication to your space.' You can keep this in mind when designing a coffee station.

'If your current coffee maker takes up too much counter space and makes your kitchen feel cluttered, it might be time for a change,' adds Fred McGill. 'Newer models are often designed to be more compact, freeing up valuable countertop real estate and contributing to a more organized and visually appealing kitchen.'

Nespresso Vertuo Next Deluxe Coffee and Espresso Machine by De'Longhi | Was $209, now $159.99 at Amazon

Nespresso Vertuo Next Deluxe Coffee and Espresso Machine by De'Longhi | Was $209, now $159.99 at Amazon
The Nespresso Vertuo may be small, but it can still produce a mighty cup of coffee. One of our favorite single-serve coffee makers, this machine is easy to use and it's made with recycled plastic. 

De'Longhi Dinamica Plus | Was $1,700, now $1,299.95 at Amazon

De'Longhi Dinamica Plus | Was $1,700, now $1,299.95 at Amazon
I'm obsessed with this deal. A $400 saving on a machine that's worth every dollar at full price is incredible. The De'Longhi machine is incredibly user-friendly and easy to customize. It can make sixteen different coffees at the touch of a button. This is the luxury coffee experience.

You can read more in our full De'Longhi Dinamica Plus review.

Café Affetto Automatic Espresso Machine| was $679, now $499 at Amazon

Café Affetto Automatic Espresso Machine| was $679, now $499 at Amazon
With a sleek appearance and a mighty 20-pump bar system, the Café Affetto is far from your average espresso machine. Our expert testera gave it 100%. 


What are the benefits of upgrading your coffee maker?

With advancements in coffee-making technology, old coffee machines may seem outdated and inefficient. 

'If your machine lacks modern features like programmable timers, adjustable brewing temperatures, or single-cup brewing options, it might be time for an upgrade,' advises Steve Spring, president of Seattle Coffee Roasters. 'Newer machines offer increased convenience and customization.'  

Coffee author, James Hyslop, leaves us with one last piece of advice: 'As a coffee expert and user I have long felt that coffee machines are not only about the coffee produced but the holistic experience of using the machine. A good coffee machine should be a pleasure to use and bring you joy and not frustration. 

'So sometimes your coffee machine works fine, produces acceptable coffee but just doesn't quite do it for you; maybe you don't like the look, maybe the features are restrictive, or maybe operating it is just unpleasurable. This is also a sure sign that you should at least consider changing coffee machines to one that will bring you joy in both experience and in the coffee it produces.'

Lola Houlton
News writer

Lola Houlton is a news writer for Homes & Gardens. She has been writing content for Future PLC for the past six years, in particular Homes & Gardens, Real Homes and GardeningEtc. She writes on a broad range of subjects, including practical household advice, recipe articles, and product reviews, working closely with experts in their fields to cover everything from heating to home organization through to house plants. Lola is a graduate, who completed her degree in Psychology at the University of Sussex. She has also spent some time working at the BBC.

With contributions from