Mopping vs wet vacuuming – which is the better cleaner for your home? I'm a home tech editor and spent hours testing products to answer this for good

Wet vacuuming has taken off in recent years as homeowners are realizing that all the time spent mopping and scrubbing can actually be saved with a smarty, handy appliance.

But how well do wet vacuums actually clean the floor? Mops are so effective because they scrub detergent into our hard floors, deep cleaning and getting into the grooves and cracks, so as a starting point, we want wet vacuums to achieve at least the same results.

Replacing a mop might be one of the many reasons to upgrade to a wet/dry vacuum, but first we need to understand whether they're as effective as they claim. As H&G's home tech editor, I've spent hours testing wet vacuums and floor care products myself to see how well they work, whether they are worth the money, and if it's time to finally ditch your mop.

Mopping vs wet vacuuming

To dive into all the differences between mops and wet vacuums, I gathered insight from experts and professional cleaners as well as testing appliances out for myself.

An important distinction: where I reference 'wet vacuums' in this article, I'm referring to those with clean water tanks and brush rolls that serve as floor cleaners, rather than the more rugged types like the Shark MessMaster we reviewed.

For more information on those, delve into our dedicated guide on things you can clean with a wet/dry vacuum.

The pros and cons of mopping

'Mopping is a more affordable option,' says Nick Valentino, VP of market operations at Bellhops. 'Anyone with a mop, a bucket, some water, and some soap can get it done, whereas wet vacuums are expensive.'

That being said, mopping is much more labor-intensive and time-consuming compared to wet vacuuming. 'If you’re mopping a huge kitchen or a big floor space, you’ll keep dunking that mop in the water, wringing it out, and then starting all over again,' says Rhonda Wilson, quality lead cleaner at FreshSpace Cleaning. 'And that’s tiring, too!'

Adding to the time-consuming nature of mopping is water replacement. For a truly clean floor, you'll want to replace the bucket water regularly so that you're not recirculating the dirty water across your floors. Wet vacuums do this automatically, utilizing separate water tanks for clean and dirty water so that the water that touches the floor is always clean.

However, as mops are powered by you, you can decide how much force you want to apply when cleaning, meaning it's easier to deep clean the grooves and cracks in your floors. You can also be more liberal with how much detergent you can use so that your floors are as fresh and sanitized as you'd like, whereas wet vacuums typically can't handle too much detergent, if any.

As Logan Taylor, professional cleaner and founder of Dazzle Company puts it, 'Mopping is a tried-and-true method that can effectively remove dirt and stains from floors. It involves in-depth cleaning that can reach into cracks and crevices, ensuring a thorough cleaning.'

There are different types of mops, too, with some able to clean more deeply (with less effort) than traditional mops, while still being more affordable than wet vacuums.

'In my experience, good steam mops are an excellent option for deep cleaning and sanitizing hard floors, such as tile, hardwood, and laminate,' explains Logan. 'They use hot steam to loosen dirt and grime while killing bacteria and germs.' For a deep clean and a minimal spend, steam mops are a strong option.

You also don't need to use any chemicals as the steam takes care of bacteria and is brilliant and loosening stains and grime.

The pros and cons of wet vacuuming

'Wet vacuuming combines vacuuming and mopping in one device, making it more efficient and capable of deep cleaning,' explains Lina DaSilva, professional cleaner and founder of Toronto Shine Cleaning. 'It also dries floors quickly by sucking up the water,' she adds, as wet vacuums are able to suck up liquid spills and dry debris.

This is why wet vacuums are becoming so popular: they're convenient, can deep clean, and do most of the work for you. They'll usually use a brush roll (or two) that sweeps the floor, sucking up any wet and dry debris while mopping the floor in the process. They'll also have points within the brush rolls that dispense clean water so that your floors are always being treated with fresh water throughout cleaning.

'Wet vacuuming is efficient and requires less physical effort, making it a great option for larger areas or heavily soiled floors,' says Logan. 'Wet vacuums also have different attachments and settings that make them versatile for various surfaces such as carpets and hard floors. It also has the added benefit of extracting excess water from floors, reducing drying time.'

I can attest to this from personal experience. From using Dyson's and Tineco's cleaners, I'm enjoying how easily and quickly I can clean all the hard floors in my home. They even have self-cleaning stations that make sure the brush rolls stay hygienic and sanitized for next time, without you having to do anything yourself (other than replacing them when necessary, typically every six months or so).

But importantly, wet vacuums are expensive. For one that'll comprehensively clean your floors, you'll be spending a few hundred dollars.

Which should I buy?

Sticking with your traditional mops is the affordable option. It will deep clean your floors but take time and lots of manual labor to do so. For a cheap upgrade, a steam mop requires less effort and is able to sanitize your floors, as Lina puts it:

'For steam mops, basic models are great for sanitizing and light cleaning but may lack the power for deeper cleaning, advanced steam mops offer features like adjustable steam levels and attachments for different surfaces.'

Wet vacuuming brings sweeping, vacuuming and mopping together (but not steaming). It's a convenient and comprehensive method that demands little effort from yourself, and they use separate clean water tanks so that your floors are always seeing fresh water. But this comes at a steep cost, so it's worth weighing up whether the convenience and deeper cleaning is worth the hundreds.

If you're looking for a steam mop, Logan Taylor recommends the Bissell PowerFresh Steam Mop. For a wet vacuum, Lina DaSilva and Nick Valentino both coincidentally recommend the Bissell CrossWave HydroSteam Plus. We've reviewed an older version of the Bissell CrossWave HydroStream and had excellent results, resulting in a rare five stars from us after thorough testing.

Although Bissell comes up a lot in the floor care conversation (it's worth taking a look through Bissell's full range), I would personally recommend the Tineco Floor One Stretch S6. I'm currently midway through testing it but already love how efficiently and effectively it tackles hard floors.

Next, discover things you can clean with a steam mop besides the floor.