I slept on Martha Stewart's surprisingly great bedsheets for a month – and they're on sale

Martha Stewart is the queen of all things home, so it should come as no surprise that she has her own line of bedding. The collection includes everything you could ever need to make your bed, including sheets, blankets, pillows, and even items like mattress toppers, all made with high-quality materials for reasonable prices. 

I’ve tested dozens of bedding products throughout my career, so I was curious to see how the Martha Stewart collection stands up against the best bed sheets and best comforters. 

I was able to test three different products from the Martha Stewart line, including a set of cotton sheets, a down-filled comforter, and two pillows. I tried them out over the course of two weeks, sleeping on them each night. 

Overall, I was really impressed with the quality and performance of all three pieces. The sheets were soft and breathable, and the comforter was cozy and warm, even on cold winter nights. The pillows were too soft for my taste, but there will definitely be people who love their plush, sink-in feel. Here’s everything I thought about the three products, as well as who I think should buy them.

Martha Stewart Sheet deal

Martha Stewart 100% Cotton Queen Sheet Set | Was $64.99, now $54.99 at Amazon
If you need some quality sheets ASAP, Martha's sheets are now on sale at Amazon. They come in a wide range of colors and are remarkably good for the price. 

View Deal

Martha Stewart Bedding Specifications

Unboxing my Martha Stewart bedding set

The three products I tested all arrived separately, and while the sheets and comforter were in nice branded packaging, the pillows were just tossed into a cardboard shipping box, which I thought was strange. 

The comforter came packaged in a plastic tote (not the most eco-friendly), and the sheets were in a fabric bag that matched the pattern. The two pillows were tightly wrapped up in a layer of plastic. I had to very carefully cut away the wrapping to get them free, and they were a bit flat at first. However, I tossed them in the dryer for 10 minutes, and they fluffed up nicely.  

Before putting the sheets onto my bed, I washed them according to the care directions. They had a slight odor initially, but that's common for bedding that’s been sitting in a warehouse waiting to be shipped. It went away after a cycle through the laundry. The sheets were also noticeably softer after laundering, which often happens with 100% cotton fabric. 

Test 1: Cotton Sheet Set

I tested out the Martha Stewart 100% Cotton Sheet Set in a pattern called Otto Geometric Light Blue. The queen-size set fit well on my mattress, which is around 14 inches thick, and I loved the colorful pattern, which features a light blue quatrefoil motif with yellow accents. The pillowcases and flat sheet have a pleated detail on the hem, and overall, it’s a very pretty set that brightens up the bedroom. I only wish that the pillowcases had a envelope closure, as they sometimes migrated off the pillow when I tossed and turned at night. 

In terms of comfort, I was really impressed with the feel and weight of these sheets. They were soft and comfortable to sleep on, keeping my partner and I warm, but I think they’re also breathable enough to use during the summer. They seem to get softer after each wash, so I think they’ll only continue to get better over time. I also like that they’re OEKO-TEX certified, which means they’ve been tested for harmful chemicals and deemed safe for human health. 

Overall, these sheets get top marks from me. I’ve reviewed dozens of different sheet sets in my career, and this one of the better budget-friendly sets I’ve tested, retailing at around $65 for a queen-size set. 

Test 2: Down Comforter

In addition to the sheets, I used the Martha Stewart Down Comforter on my bed for two weeks. The outer shell is made from a blend of cotton and lyocell, which is a type of rayon, and it’s super smooth and soft to the touch. In fact, it felt so good that I didn't bother to add a duvet cover.

This comforter features baffle box stitching that keeps the blend of down and feathers evenly distributed across the blanket. It's cozy and lofty without being too puffy. 

We keep our house quite cool during the winter – generally around 60 degrees Fahrenheit at night – so this blanket was absolutely amazing for chilly nights. When paired with a lightweight quilt, it provided the perfect amount of warmth, keeping both me and my partner comfortable all night long. 

The brand claims the blanket’s medium-weight is suitable for all-season use, but as someone who sleeps hot, I think it would be too warm for the summer. But for the winter in New England, it was absolutely ideal. Not to mention that it’s notably more affordable than many other down comforters, costing around $130 for a king size.

Test 3: Down Alternative Bed Pillows

Finally, I tried out the Martha Stewart Down Alternative Bed Pillows in a standard queen size. These pillows come in a pack of two, which costs $50, and honestly, they’re a little pricey for what they are. The exterior of the pillows is a cotton-polyester blend, and they’re filled with regular polyester fiberfill. They’re definitely not as thick as they appear in the product photos, but they do have a cute light blue piping detail around the edges. 

As a side sleeper, these pillows simply didn’t provide enough support for me. I like a fairly thick pillow that keeps my head supported, and these pillows were way too soft and plush. My partner liked the pillow better than I did, saying that it was comfortable to cushion his head when he was sleeping on his back. 

Overall, I think these pillows are better suited for back sleepers or stomach sleepers, but even then, you can definitely find similar options that are much cheaper: $25 for a regular fiberfill pillow is a bit steep. 

Cleaning my Martha Stewart bedding set

Another great thing about the Martha Stewart bedding is that many of the items are machine-washable. The sheet set and pillows can both be put in the washing machine and dryer, making them easy to maintain. In fact, the sheets actually get softer after washing, helping to improve their texture the more you use them.

Unfortunately, the comforter isn’t as easy to clean, but that’s not surprising given that it’s filled with down. The care tag reads 'dry clean only' in large letters, so you will need to pay to have it laundered. To that end, it’s probably a good idea to use a duvet cover on it, especially if you have pets who climb on the bed.

Should you buy Martha Stewart bedding?

All things considered, I was pleasantly surprised by the Martha Stewart bedding line. Despite the reasonable prices, the products were all well-made and comfortable to sleep on. I particularly liked the sheets, which come in both solid colors and fun patterns, and the down comforter was a perfect option for cold nights in the winter. I wasn’t sold on the pillows, which were too soft for me, but if you sleep on your back or stomach, they might be a better fit for you. 

Overall, the bedding is a great budget-friendly option for your home, and it should make your bedroom feel like a little lap of luxury.